My idea for this week’s top ten was inspired by an article on a new doll. (See the full article here. And please note that this is probably the only time I will source Fox News, and it’s apropos that it’s an article that angers me.)
It's an old article, but it was just brought to my attention.
A European manufacturer created a doll specifically for breastfeeding. This is apparently extremely upsetting to some people.
I was very angry by what the article insinuated about breastfeeding and exposing young children to it. They made it out as though it is an “adult” activity, not suited for young children.
Which led me to wonder if they realize what breastfeeding is? I'll key you in- it actually requires a young child for it to work.
Many people get a little squirmy over breastfeeding.
I always want to ask them if they realize the milk for their cereal is just cow breastmilk?
Even more get squirmy over the idea of nursing a toddler. I’ve been the recipient of many odd looks when I say I’m “still” nursing Paityn. And I think that it is this discomfort that gave birth to this “news” article and people’s discomfort with a toy.
There’s nothing wrong with deciding not to breastfeed. I certainly do not think that choosing to use formula is wrong. Paityn was fed some formula in her first year as I couldn’t pump enough. But, equally, there is nothing disgusting or perverse about choosing to breastfeed.
Giving me the idea for this week’s top ten:
Top Ten Reasons I Still (Yes, Still) Nurse my Toddler
10. Paityn benefits nutritionally. As good of an eater as she is, there are some days where she has little interest in eating anything besides fruit and toast.
In the second year (12-23 months), 448 mL (about 1 ¾ cups) of breastmilk provides:
· 29% of energy requirements
· 43% of protein requirements
· 36% of calcium requirements
· 75% of vitamin A requirements
· 76% of folate requirements
· 94% of vitamin B12 requirements
· 60% of vitamin C requirements
(Dewey 2001)
9. Paityn gets sick very infrequently, and I do believe it’s directly related to nursing (a conclusion supported by many studies). And when I am sick with the same illness as her, it lasts a very short duration for her. She has the benefit of receiving my antibodies and continued immune factors (which some studies have shown actually increase in the second year).
8. It’s healthy for me.
For mothers, breastfeeding reduces the risk of ovarian, breast, endometrial, and uterine cancers, among other health benefits. It decreases the risks of osteoporosis and rheumatoid arthritis.
7. Being a toddler can be tough.
It’s full of developmental changes, growth spurts, emotional changes and increased independence. Nursing provides a continued, secure, and familiar connection with me for Paityn.
Paityn has no “lovey” like a blanket, a special toy, or a pacifier. She turns completely to me for comfort and security.
6. It helps Paityn's growth into independence.
Studies show "there are statistically significant tendencies for conduct disorder scores to decline with increasing duration of breastfeeding."
Elizabeth Baldwin sums up the psychological and developmental findings in “Extended Breastfeeding and the Law” as follows:
"Meeting a child's dependency needs is the key to helping that child achieve independence. And children outgrow these needs according to their own unique timetable. Children who achieve independence at their own pace are more secure in that independence then children forced into independence prematurely."
5. It’s a personal decision.
Breastfeeding is a very personal decision. Making that decision out of guilt or pressure isn’t healthy.
It’s equally unhealthy for me to refuse my daughter comfort and nutrition because of societal hang-ups.
Mothers make decisions all the time: to breastfeed or not, and if so, how long; to work or stay home; to homeschool or public school. The majority of mothers are making the best decisions they can for their family.
4. It provides valuable nutrition when Paityn does get sick.
Several weeks ago, Paityn was sick and had no interest in drinking or eating. Did you ever try to force liquids into a stubborn and sick child? But she would nurse, so I didn’t have to try to get her to eat solids or drink.
3. It helps Paityn emotionally. When she gets hurt, upset, or sick, nursing provides comfort beyond a hug or a kiss.
According to Elizabeth Baldwin in "Extended Breastfeeding and the Law":
"…nursing past infancy helps little ones make a gradual transition to childhood."
2. Paityn doesn’t want to stop and is quite attached to her na-nas.
Establishing nursing was difficult for us. I spent a year pumping at work. I spent months nursing through the night, through teething, through developmental milestones. We have bonded over nursing.
Why would I destroy those months and years of work by forcing her to stop when she clearly is not yet ready? To bend to societal pressure?
I’m afraid I’ve never been a very good conformist.
1. It’s completely natural and normal, especially in European countries, to extend nursing beyond the first year.
I truly feel American society has far too many hangups due to our over-sexualization of women. Somehow, breastfeeding, since it involves the breasts (gasp!), got lumped into the “sex” category, and so becomes something almost perverse, especially when it involves any child able to verbally ask for it.
As mammals, we are equipped with mammary glands to provide milk to our young. There’s nothing gross or weird or crazy about it. And teaching our children, both boys and girls, that it is a natural and acceptable way of feeding babies is completely appropriate.
Even if you don’t like the doll.
References:
Dewey KG, Finley DA, Lonnerdal B. Breast milk volume and composition during late lactation (7-20 months). J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr 1984 Nov;3(5):713-20.
Goldman AS, Goldblum RM, Garza C. Immunologic components in human milk during the second year of lactation. Acta Paediatr Scand. 1983 May;72(3):461-2.
Baldwin, EN. Extended Breastfeeding and the Law. Mothering 1993 (Spring);66:88.